Page 1 of 1

Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu Sep 22, 2022 9:10 pm
by Tez
So a warning this is a long post, but you might find it interesting. It's about Sangharakshita and the Triratna scandal.

This is a follow up on the post I wrote asking if it was OK to study someone who had Behaved in an appalling way. This referred to Sang, the founder of The Triratna movement in the UK. I looked further into him and I was horrified. Essentially he was a sexual predator who used his position and manipulated buddhism to get straight men to have sex with him, one of whom committed suicide, with possibly two more doing the same. However learned he was on Buddhism (which is questionable), It invalidates his teaching As he clearly had no ability to walk the path he has encouraged others to follow.

As for the Triratna movement, they're still in denial as to his crimes. They started by covering it up, then they begrudgingly admitted the minimum they had to, releasing a report that called Sangharakshita's behaviour "unwise" rather than criminal and wicked. In the report, 13 % Triratna members questioned Said that either they themselves, or someone they knew, had “experienced sexual misconduct by either Sangharakshita or other Triratna order members, in past and recent times”. Triratna has made no effort at restitution to the victims. The report spent more time praising him than calling him to account, and it's hidden away in a barely noticed part of their website. One particularly egregious passage said this:-

"One irony of the current situation is that the understanding of ethics that we have learned, ultimately, from Sangharakshita has informed the criticisms of him that we make in this report."

Essentially it's saying that Sangharakshita gave them the ethical standards they needed to judge him as having acted unethically. This is a shocking statement! Apparently Sangharakshita was undone by his own enlightened teaching and sense of ethics. What teaching in ethics do you need to know sexual assault is wrong? They are trying to twist his crimes into another positive. Triratna was built on a bed of manipulation and abuse of the vulnerable, one they still refuse to reckon with.

The question I have is is Triratna a writeoff? I've really enjoyed my time at the centre and it's set me on my path to Buddhism. The people who go are kind and committed, and I have seen nothing to suggest the teachers are acting unethically. But a guest speaker recommended two books by Sangharakshita to me (before I knew about his crimes), one I bought which are sold in their shop. Ironically one of them was about the ethics of Buddhism. I'm angry the centre sells his books, and ideally they would dissasociate from him entirely, which isn't going to happen as he's too embedded in their philosophy. Part of me wants to keep going to the centre, but I'm appalled by their past behaviour and lack of contrition. I should note that my feelings of sadness and anger are nothing compared to the suffering of Sangharakshita.

So, should I stay and make my feelings known, or should I find somewhere else to help me walk the path? Thoughts and comments very welcome

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu Sep 22, 2022 11:45 pm
by Johnny Dangerous
As I mentioned in the earlier thread, if I were you I would leave. Not just due to the scandal and how it was handled, but because IMO their take on Dharma is also shaky.

That doesn’t mean they are all terrible people, that everything you learned is invalid or anything. I just think your time is probably better spent with people who have a better, more grounded Buddhist education and who are not connected to sangarakshita.

Just my two cents.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu Sep 22, 2022 11:54 pm
by Konchog Thogme Jampa
Have confidence in yourself and just leave walk out that door and just keep on walking

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Fri Sep 23, 2022 8:48 am
by PeterC
Should you leave? Definitely. Don't make a big deal of it, just stop turning up. There are so many sanghas with genuine, qualified teachers out there that there's absolutely no reason to get involved in something built around someone as unpleasant and unqualified as Lingwood

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Fri Sep 23, 2022 11:15 am
by Könchok Thrinley
Yes, you should leave.

Doesn't matter how much effort and energy you put into that community. Just don't go there anymore. Find a proper teacher.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Fri Sep 23, 2022 2:39 pm
by DewachenVagabond
Find a community that doesn't have such a questionable lineage. And I'm not just talking about the failure of ethics. Sangharakshita's connection to a legitimate lineage was always questionable.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2022 1:14 pm
by PSM
FWBO was the first Buddhist related group I was ever involved in about 20 years ago. The people in the group were good people, but I'm afraid that a lot of the teachings were twisted/contaminated/made up and Shantarakshita is an ethical embarassment. Both of these fundamentally cripple that organisation in my view.

Since then I've been involved with proper lineage teachers who do actually 1) know what they are on about 2) walk the talk & 3) have realised people in their lineage to this day. Why settle for anything less? Leave.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Wed May 03, 2023 11:53 am
by CheersDrive
As someone who experienced bullying by an order member, trust your gut.

There is both light and dark within Triratna. The teaching aspects are actually very good. The dark- completely unwilling to address bad behaviour. It's toxic passivity around abusive behaviour is a very real concern. It's the ideal environment for abusers to thrive.

Naivety around manipulative and exploitative people and the absence of being held accountable for such behaviour is why I left.

Their solution to bad relationships is to facilitate mediation. That's appropriate for 2 adults who are honest and want reconciliation. It is not appropriate for a relationship where one person misuses their power and uses manipulative communication to make the subordinate question their sanity.

I tried every avenue known to me to raise my concerns. Nobody acknowledged any of them. In 2 years, nobody has contacted me to see if I'm okay. Nobody could assure me that this order member would be reprimanded, and in fact, is still regarded in high esteem.

In summary I would say that my primary experience of Triratna has been a complete lack of empathy and care.

I guess I'm the scapegoat and have served my purpose, until the next one...

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu May 04, 2023 3:21 am
by PeterC
CheersDrive wrote: Wed May 03, 2023 11:53 am As someone who experienced bullying by an order member, trust your gut.

There is both light and dark within Triratna. The teaching aspects are actually very good. The dark- completely unwilling to address bad behaviour. It's toxic passivity around abusive behaviour is a very real concern. It's the ideal environment for abusers to thrive.

Naivety around manipulative and exploitative people and the absence of being held accountable for such behaviour is why I left.

Their solution to bad relationships is to facilitate mediation. That's appropriate for 2 adults who are honest and want reconciliation. It is not appropriate for a relationship where one person misuses their power and uses manipulative communication to make the subordinate question their sanity.

I tried every avenue known to me to raise my concerns. Nobody acknowledged any of them. In 2 years, nobody has contacted me to see if I'm okay. Nobody could assure me that this order member would be reprimanded, and in fact, is still regarded in high esteem.

In summary I would say that my primary experience of Triratna has been a complete lack of empathy and care.

I guess I'm the scapegoat and have served my purpose, until the next one...
Sorry to hear about this. Are you in contact with a real sangha now?

You can't expect empathy and care from an organization that condones abuse, any more than you can expect it from an abusive person, and you can't try to mentally trade off the abuse against the positives (if there are any in this case). You just need to move on.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu May 04, 2023 1:51 pm
by Knotty Veneer
Leave immediately. Why would you want to belong to any organization that would have Suella Braverman as a member?

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu May 04, 2023 1:58 pm
by PSM
CheersDrive wrote: Wed May 03, 2023 11:53 am As someone who experienced bullying by an order member, trust your gut.
Definitely.
There is both light and dark within Triratna. The teaching aspects are actually very good.
I’m not sure I’d agree the teaching is good. They have a history of mixing plenty of non-dharma into dharma, such as Nietzsche. There are so many valid lineages I don’t see the point in being involved with the FWBO.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Thu May 04, 2023 3:57 pm
by Johnny Dangerous
PSM wrote: Thu May 04, 2023 1:58 pm
CheersDrive wrote: Wed May 03, 2023 11:53 am As someone who experienced bullying by an order member, trust your gut.
Definitely.
There is both light and dark within Triratna. The teaching aspects are actually very good.
I’m not sure I’d agree the teaching is good. They have a history of mixing plenty of non-dharma into dharma, such as Nietzsche. There are so many valid lineages I don’t see the point in being involved with the FWBO.
This has always been my feeling. Even apart from all the ethical stuff what is actually taught by the FWBO is kind of a mess. Given that legit teaching in this day and age is not hard to come by, I can’t see any good reason for people to stay.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Fri May 05, 2023 1:56 pm
by jet.urgyen
Tez wrote: Thu Sep 22, 2022 9:10 pm So a warning this is a long post, but you might find it interesting. It's about Sangharakshita and the Triratna scandal.

This is a follow up on the post I wrote asking if it was OK to study someone who had Behaved in an appalling way. This referred to Sang, the founder of The Triratna movement in the UK. I looked further into him and I was horrified. Essentially he was a sexual predator who used his position and manipulated buddhism to get straight men to have sex with him, one of whom committed suicide, with possibly two more doing the same. However learned he was on Buddhism (which is questionable), It invalidates his teaching As he clearly had no ability to walk the path he has encouraged others to follow.

As for the Triratna movement, they're still in denial as to his crimes. They started by covering it up, then they begrudgingly admitted the minimum they had to, releasing a report that called Sangharakshita's behaviour "unwise" rather than criminal and wicked. In the report, 13 % Triratna members questioned Said that either they themselves, or someone they knew, had “experienced sexual misconduct by either Sangharakshita or other Triratna order members, in past and recent times”. Triratna has made no effort at restitution to the victims. The report spent more time praising him than calling him to account, and it's hidden away in a barely noticed part of their website. One particularly egregious passage said this:-

"One irony of the current situation is that the understanding of ethics that we have learned, ultimately, from Sangharakshita has informed the criticisms of him that we make in this report."

Essentially it's saying that Sangharakshita gave them the ethical standards they needed to judge him as having acted unethically. This is a shocking statement! Apparently Sangharakshita was undone by his own enlightened teaching and sense of ethics. What teaching in ethics do you need to know sexual assault is wrong? They are trying to twist his crimes into another positive. Triratna was built on a bed of manipulation and abuse of the vulnerable, one they still refuse to reckon with.

The question I have is is Triratna a writeoff? I've really enjoyed my time at the centre and it's set me on my path to Buddhism. The people who go are kind and committed, and I have seen nothing to suggest the teachers are acting unethically. But a guest speaker recommended two books by Sangharakshita to me (before I knew about his crimes), one I bought which are sold in their shop. Ironically one of them was about the ethics of Buddhism. I'm angry the centre sells his books, and ideally they would dissasociate from him entirely, which isn't going to happen as he's too embedded in their philosophy. Part of me wants to keep going to the centre, but I'm appalled by their past behaviour and lack of contrition. I should note that my feelings of sadness and anger are nothing compared to the suffering of Sangharakshita.

So, should I stay and make my feelings known, or should I find somewhere else to help me walk the path? Thoughts and comments very welcome
If you have seriuous concerns and are unsure, you should bring it up, people's responses about it are important so you can see who also have, who had but stayed, who had and wet away, etc.

But also, there's no impediment for you to participate in also in another group, you'll know if you are really in a sect if people complain about you doing that.


And in my personal opinion, you don't swim where predators lurk. It is foolish.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Fri May 05, 2023 7:22 pm
by Nalanda
This is not a Buddhist school, so, regardless of controversies, there's really no need to be involved in it.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Mon May 08, 2023 9:51 pm
by aknishtha
You should leave, I was in Sogyal's Rigpa Sangha, the moment I learned about the scandals around him I left because they were in denial.
A bodhisattva would never behave in a way to harm beings, so I would not follow anyone who can't hold that simple Shila precept.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Tue May 09, 2023 2:33 am
by PeterC
Knotty Veneer wrote: Thu May 04, 2023 1:51 pm Leave immediately. Why would you want to belong to any organization that would have Suella Braverman as a member?
She's a member? That explains a lot. In a way, it's the perfect sangha for her - founded on abuse, gaslighting and denials.

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Tue May 09, 2023 7:21 am
by treehuggingoctopus
Knotty Veneer wrote: Thu May 04, 2023 1:51 pmSuella Braverman
:jawdrop:

Re: Sangharakshita, Triratna, and should I leave

Posted: Tue May 09, 2023 8:23 am
by Kim O'Hara
Our (collective) answer to the Op's question - "should I leave?" - has been perfectly clear almost from the beginning of the thread.
The OP has asked no further questions in the many months since that first one.
And now we're moving from reasonable critiques of Triratna to gossip and abuse.

Time to pull the plug.

:namaste:
Kim