Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
What would you consider the most comfortable size for bodhi seeds on a mala? The smaller sized seeds like 9mm make for very expensive malas, but wouldn't 10.5mm or even 11.5 mm be more comfortable? What is your experience? What bead size do you find most comfortable for a (wooden) mala regardless of monetary value?
I currently have a sandalwood mala, bead size I would guess a little over 9mm, and it is not the most comfortable for my fairly large hands. I am considering purchasing a bodhi seed mala (Ziziphus budhensis, phoenix eye) in the future.
A few years ago, there was a good, informative thread on the correct, authentic bodhi seed mala here. What I am concerned with now is simple utility.
I currently have a sandalwood mala, bead size I would guess a little over 9mm, and it is not the most comfortable for my fairly large hands. I am considering purchasing a bodhi seed mala (Ziziphus budhensis, phoenix eye) in the future.
A few years ago, there was a good, informative thread on the correct, authentic bodhi seed mala here. What I am concerned with now is simple utility.
- Konchog Thogme Jampa
- Posts: 1175
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2017 4:48 am
- Location: Saha World/Hard to Take
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
I used to have a huge mala when I was a Monk it was a lot of fun huge beads and dropping from my hand by my side down to my knees
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
My japa mala (108 beads) is tulsi wood, and the beads are oval. About 1 cm wide, 1.5 cm long. My wrist mala (54 beads) is jade and probably 7 or 8 mm beads. I find the larger wooden beads much more comfortable to use - both the size and the feel of the wood.
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
I have a bodhiseed mala with normally large beads. For the purpose of doing recitations, I think it is great but that is all I really use it for.
Most bodhiseed malas that I have seen have beads that are probably 11, 12 mm or more.
Most bodhiseed malas that I have seen have beads that are probably 11, 12 mm or more.
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
I settled on a bodhi seed mala (Ziziphus budhensis) with 11.5 mm average diameter beads for the price of €62.80.
Here is a stock photo from the seller's website:
https://dharmacraft.shop/product_667/tr ... 15-mm.html
Ships from Lithuania.
Here is a stock photo from the seller's website:
https://dharmacraft.shop/product_667/tr ... 15-mm.html
Ships from Lithuania.
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
This reminds me of the time I bought a huge mala. The beads were the largest Bodhi seeds I had ever seen and it was the full 108. I bought it largely to support the shop which was owned by a Lama known to me. Looped around double it still reached my waist when I wore it around my neck. I got some odd looks on the train home. But it was many years ago when I was young and dashing!
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Archie2009 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 12:31 pm I settled on a bodhi seed mala (Ziziphus budhensis) with 11.5 mm average diameter beads for the price of €62.80.
https://dharmacraft.shop/product_667/tr ... 15-mm.html
Ships from Lithuania.
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2018 3:04 am
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Following is a bit offtopic, but could be important.
https://dharmacraft.shop/62-mandala-tal ... n-rinpoche
As far as I understand, Gangchen Rinpoche was one of the influential teachers who went against the advice of His Holiness the Dalai Lama on you-know-what taboo topic.
Would anyone here particularly trust or recommend acquiring "neutral" materials bought from a shop that carries blessed items by people who associate with you-know-what?
Of course, everything is meant to be purified and consecrated for one's use in practice, but I personally feel like taking maximum distance anyway and not support a type of business which acquires supplies from the aficionados of you-know-what.
The shop looked rather inviting until I came across this:Archie2009 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 12:31 pm https://dharmacraft.shop/product_667/tr ... 15-mm.html
Ships from Lithuania.
https://dharmacraft.shop/62-mandala-tal ... n-rinpoche
As far as I understand, Gangchen Rinpoche was one of the influential teachers who went against the advice of His Holiness the Dalai Lama on you-know-what taboo topic.
Would anyone here particularly trust or recommend acquiring "neutral" materials bought from a shop that carries blessed items by people who associate with you-know-what?
Of course, everything is meant to be purified and consecrated for one's use in practice, but I personally feel like taking maximum distance anyway and not support a type of business which acquires supplies from the aficionados of you-know-what.
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
jeez, these damned preposterous prices..
stay open, spread love
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
what do you mean "good"?
around Swayambhu in KTM it is possible to find 11 mm seeds mala for 3,5 USD. if they see white face the price will be 4 times more though.
around Swayambhu in KTM it is possible to find 11 mm seeds mala for 3,5 USD. if they see white face the price will be 4 times more though.
stay open, spread love
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Good, well made, will last a lifetime. I don't do street haggling. I liked it, paid the price asked, and that was the end of it. We in West are wealthy, compared to Tibetans. We can afford it. It helps everyone. There is a saying in ceremonial magick, "Thou shalt buy the single egg of a black hen without haggling."
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Frankly, it hadn't crossed my mind. I had never heard of Gangchen Rinpoche.ohwedodzogchennow wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 4:49 pm Following is a bit offtopic, but could be important.
The shop looked rather inviting until I came across this:Archie2009 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 12:31 pm https://dharmacraft.shop/product_667/tr ... 15-mm.html
Ships from Lithuania.
https://dharmacraft.shop/62-mandala-tal ... n-rinpoche
As far as I understand, Gangchen Rinpoche was one of the influential teachers who went against the advice of His Holiness the Dalai Lama on you-know-what taboo topic.
Would anyone here particularly trust or recommend acquiring "neutral" materials bought from a shop that carries blessed items by people who associate with you-know-what?
Of course, everything is meant to be purified and consecrated for one's use in practice, but I personally feel like taking maximum distance anyway and not support a type of business which acquires supplies from the aficionados of you-know-what.
It is hard enough to find a shop like this selling authentic dharma implements that is located within the EU instead of the USA. I will have to pay only €7.30 shipping and no customs and import duties. Shipping and customs duties from the USA these days would have more than doubled the price of the object.
Furthermore, I had email contact with the store and they seemed fine people.
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Are you suggesting I cancel my order, buy a return plane ticket to Kathmandu, haggle my way into a $3.50 11.5 mm average diameter bodhi mala of the type Ziziphus budhensis, and make it safely back home all for less than €62.80 + €7.30?
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
Yup. They are getting a little harder to find these days as well. I was lucky 5 years back when I went into my local "new-agey" type store that has a small Dharma corner. Their guy had just come back from Nepal with a bunch of stuff. They had 2 really good bodhiseed malas that were kept hidden behind the counter, and lucky I asked about one. I wasn't thinking twice about the price either.Malcolm wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 6:10 pmGood, well made, will last a lifetime. I don't do street haggling. I liked it, paid the price asked, and that was the end of it. We in West are wealthy, compared to Tibetans. We can afford it. It helps everyone. There is a saying in ceremonial magick, "Thou shalt buy the single egg of a black hen without haggling."
Turns out that was the last time they brought anything like that back due to the sky rocketing prices. Someone said that a lot of Chinese were now trying to "capitalize" on the popularity of these kinds of items and were snapping them up where they could to resell at a nice profit.
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
In contrast to the scary Gangchen Rinpoche talismans quoted above, here is another item they sold:
https://dharmacraft.shop/product_155/bu ... 45-cm.html
"Buddhist Thangka "Great Dzogchen Teacher Garab Dorje", painting in accordance with instructions from Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche. Traditional Tibetan painting — real colors on canvas — 35 x 45 cm"
"This real painted thangka (tib.: ཐང་ཀ་) of Great Dzogchen Teacher Garab Dorje (Tibetan: དགའ་རབ་རྡོ་རྗེ་, Wylie: dga’ rab rdo rje) also known as Prahevajra was painted by old Tibetan family living in Kathmandu.
Garab Dorje was the semi-historical first human teacher of the Ati Yoga or Dzogchen (Great Perfection) teachings according to Tibetan Buddhist tradition.
This paintins was made precisely in accordance with instructions received from Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche. So it completely fits for ritual purposes of the member of Dzogchen Community.
IMPORTANT!!! THIS IS REAL PAINTING, NOT PRINT!!!
Unlike most cheap (and sometimes not so) thangkas sold for the tourists in the shops of Thamel, this painting is made in accordance with all religious canons. So, you can be sure - all the proportions and colors are correct."
https://dharmacraft.shop/product_155/bu ... 45-cm.html
"Buddhist Thangka "Great Dzogchen Teacher Garab Dorje", painting in accordance with instructions from Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche. Traditional Tibetan painting — real colors on canvas — 35 x 45 cm"
"This real painted thangka (tib.: ཐང་ཀ་) of Great Dzogchen Teacher Garab Dorje (Tibetan: དགའ་རབ་རྡོ་རྗེ་, Wylie: dga’ rab rdo rje) also known as Prahevajra was painted by old Tibetan family living in Kathmandu.
Garab Dorje was the semi-historical first human teacher of the Ati Yoga or Dzogchen (Great Perfection) teachings according to Tibetan Buddhist tradition.
This paintins was made precisely in accordance with instructions received from Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche. So it completely fits for ritual purposes of the member of Dzogchen Community.
IMPORTANT!!! THIS IS REAL PAINTING, NOT PRINT!!!
Unlike most cheap (and sometimes not so) thangkas sold for the tourists in the shops of Thamel, this painting is made in accordance with all religious canons. So, you can be sure - all the proportions and colors are correct."
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
I thought that I remember Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche saying that Guru Garab Dorje’s right leg should be tucked inward and his left leg slightly extended (in other words the opposite of the above Thangka. Perhaps I’m mistaken here, but I’m pretty sure that I remember the Chögyal saying this).
Of course sometimes it’s the opposite with other Deities, however in this case I believe that his right leg should be tucked inward and his left leg slightly extended, as I’d mentioned:
[image link removed]
Of course sometimes it’s the opposite with other Deities, however in this case I believe that his right leg should be tucked inward and his left leg slightly extended, as I’d mentioned:
[image link removed]
Last edited by Sādhaka on Mon Aug 01, 2022 10:00 am, edited 3 times in total.
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
See the drawing in the book Guruyoga, page 119. Left leg tucked inward, exactly as the above thangka.Sādhaka wrote: ↑Mon Aug 01, 2022 9:28 am I thought that I remember Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche saying that Guru Garab Dorje’s right leg should be tucked inward and his left leg slightly extended (in other words the opposite of the above Thangka. Perhaps I’m mistaken here, but I’m pretty sure that I remember the Chögyal saying this).
Of course sometimes it’s the opposite with other Deities, however in this case I believe that his right leg should be tucked inward and his left leg slightly extended, as I’d mentioned:
[image link removed]
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
I’ve noticed that in every other Dzogchen Community text including the Tun Book, that Garab Dorje is depicted with his right leg tucked more inward, and left leg slightly extended.
https://cdn3.volusion.com/a2fgn.7fypc/v ... 1353915173
And as I’d said, that’s just what I remember Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche saying. Yet as I’d said too, I could also be misremembering what he had stated during that teaching. I mean not that he said the opposite of what I’m saying; just that he could have ended that teaching with saying that it doesn’t matter either way. But I’m pretty sure that he said that it does matter, and is as I’ve said above….
https://cdn3.volusion.com/a2fgn.7fypc/v ... 1353915173
And as I’d said, that’s just what I remember Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche saying. Yet as I’d said too, I could also be misremembering what he had stated during that teaching. I mean not that he said the opposite of what I’m saying; just that he could have ended that teaching with saying that it doesn’t matter either way. But I’m pretty sure that he said that it does matter, and is as I’ve said above….
Last edited by Sādhaka on Mon Aug 01, 2022 2:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 1586
- Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2020 10:39 pm
Re: Optimal seed size for bodhi mala from practical point of view
In The Precious Vase on page 16 there is a drawing of Garab Dorje with the right leg drawn inwards as well. In everything else it is identical to the image from Guruyoga. What to make of this?