karmanyingpo wrote: ↑Sat Dec 12, 2020 6:08 am
You are right that they are spreading. I just wonder why sanghas or teachers don't try to find ways to spread them even more. Valid point about karma and dharma but with some of these all you need to do is look and see and you benefit which isn't the case with dharma talks and teachings for example.
I hope I don't come off the wrong way, I am sure there is a good reason why there aren't more efforts to widely spread these things even more than they already are spread. I am not a teacher and I am sure those teachers are way more wiser and compassionate then me
but I just asked to get a better understanding of why. Yes karma is involved but if we follow that way of thinking too much then it becomes way too passive and we may end up not trying hard enough to benefit others because we figure they get whatever there karma makes them deserve. So there is some balancing there I think.
Thanks for your response btw.
KN
Well, every non-Buddhist I have ever shown them to has been at the very least pleasantly receptive and intrigued.
As another poster reminded me earlier today, "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink." I suppose teachers could stand on the street corners waving them and raving about their benefits, but how many "normal citizens" would just hurry by, avoiding the cultish-looking weirdo? Even many Buddhists probably have doubts about their efficacy. "Here I am sweating away in zazen for 20 years with a stiff back, and you are telling me all my efforts are worth less than a glance at a drawing? Too good to be true!" Or, "So why did I bother with those 300,000 Ngondro prostrations, then?" Or, "I chant Amida Butsu's name 800 times a day, which purifies me to an even greater extent." And so on.
In a way, the question is like a Christian asking, "Why doesn't the Gospel spread everywhere when God offers such an amazing free gift of salvation through simple surrender to Christ?" All religions will only spread as far as people are receptive to them. Who can say why you and I are more receptive to "Liberation through Seeing" than we are through "simple and complete faith in Jesus?" Karma? Past merit? Sharp perception? Other causes and conditions arising from reality in general?
But since "liberation by seeing" devices are so easy to spread and so beneficial, I have confidence they will indeed spread.
