Moderator: Tibetan Buddhism moderators
AilurusFulgens wrote:a nityasiddha mantra i.e. "eternally or inherently perfect" and can yield the highest mantrasiddhi even to a person, who has not been initiated into it, but chants it devoutly?
Namdrol wrote:AilurusFulgens wrote:a nityasiddha mantra i.e. "eternally or inherently perfect" and can yield the highest mantrasiddhi even to a person, who has not been initiated into it, but chants it devoutly?
This concept does not exist in Vajrayāna.
N
AilurusFulgens wrote:[Now, this would then presuppose that the above mentioned Bhutanese adept received an initiation in the Vajra Guru Mantra from someone qualified somewhere at sometime in his life.
AilurusFulgens wrote:Thank you, Namdrol for the clarification. Still at least partially the question remains i.e. let us say that your average Joe Sixpack decides one morning to sit down and commit to reciting the Vajra Guru Mantra, that he simply got from the internet and without being initiated into it, 600 million times with as much devotion as he can muster.
AilurusFulgens wrote:Your help is much appreciated, Namdrol, thank you. Please forgive me, if my questions appear somewhat odd, but I would have one additional query.
I do not want to descend into any miracle mongering or anything similar, but I do have a genuine interest in clarifying certain things.
Do in Tibetan Vajrayana exist teachings, which would make it possible to cause Padmasambhava to appear to a sufficiently accomplished practitioner not only in dreams or a meditative vision, but physically and materially in his svarupa (i.e. not under any disguise such as an old farmer, etc.)?
A. Fulgens
AlexanderS wrote:Would it be pointless for me to recite the vajra guru mantra without initiation? Pointless as in little benefit.
Namdrol wrote:AlexanderS wrote:Would it be pointless for me to recite the vajra guru mantra without initiation? Pointless as in little benefit.
If you have faith in Guru Rinpoche, you can recite it without intitiation.
AilurusFulgens wrote:
Would this merely lead the practitioner to a qualified teacher...?
AilurusFulgens wrote:
What would then be the results of reciting the Vajra Guru mantra without an initiation?
Would this merely lead the practitioner to a qualified teacher for further guidance or would this also imply some other results and if so, which?
A. Fulgens
narraboth wrote:Actually there's no rule saying that you can not chant mantra without initiation, except some special mantra.

Namdrol wrote:narraboth wrote:Actually there's no rule saying that you can not chant mantra without initiation, except some special mantra.
yes, actually there are.
Dharanis from sutras, however are different.
narraboth wrote:Namdrol wrote:narraboth wrote:Actually there's no rule saying that you can not chant mantra without initiation, except some special mantra.
yes, actually there are.
Dharanis from sutras, however are different.
depends on what you mean for 'sutras'. I think we call Tara tantra 'sutra' in China... no matter what we still chant tare mantra.
Amoghapasa is a tantra, Manjusri root tantra is a tantra, they are all huge texts, and many other 'tantras'...
People, especially chinese buddhists, chant many of them without even LUNG, and there are many signs of 'siddhis'.
Yes, there is a line saying 'without initiation, getting siddhi is like pressing oil from sands'. but I don't think it can be understood as you won't be benefited by simply reciting mani, tare tu tare, vajra guru, arapachana.... at least i haven't heard any tibetan lama suggested that. (Tibetan themselves don't worry this)
Most of lama indicate that so-called practice in that saying is strictly tantric practice such as two stages. A senior Gelug-Nyingma master said as long as you don't do self generation, you can visualise dieties in front and chant mantra, it's not a problem that you haven't got initiation. There are also many similar teachings.
alpha wrote:What's the proper way of reciting the OM BENDZA GURU mantra.
Is there a visualization running in parallel with the recitation?
Users browsing this forum: jigmeeaton and 7 guests