username wrote:heart wrote:Please feel free to explain what Rinpoche been adding? I have no idea what you consider new in Rinpoche's commentary.
So now you know what a commentary means, are you saying his commentary is nothing new and a complete copy of a previous one by someone else?
username wrote:Chokyi Nyima's doesn't cover all and is not as refernced/scholarly but he is a great teacher in that too as usual and almost a complete great new teaching
Obviously because you believed Gyatrul Rinpoches book was a commentary on the same text as Chokyi Nyima Rinpoche commented on in his book. This is not the case and you already admitted your mistake. Now you can't state what it is that is lacking in his commentary nor what the "great new teaching" consist of I am afraid I have to conclude that you don't have a clue what you are talking about.