Is the development of ~ a prerequisite for enlightenment?: SN 12.70
Clairaudience: DN 2, DN 11
Ending of the taints/effluents (asava): DN 2,DN 11
Mind-reading: DN 2, DN 11, AN 3.60
Passing away and reappearance of beings: DN 2, DN 11
Recollection of past lives: DN 2, DN 11
As a miracle: AN 3.60
As the fruit of five-factored noble concentration: AN 5.28
How to reduce a pile of wood to its constituent elements: AN 6.41
Drawbacks of ~: DN 11
A monk displays his ~: SN 41.4
Beware: you can't hide from those with ~: AN 3.40
"The Four Bases of Power" in The Wings to Awakening (Thanissaro)
Nosta wrote:Is there any advice, on Sutras, about someone revealing or not revealing his own siddhis?
Nosta wrote:Thank you very much
Nosta wrote:By the way, access to insight is just Theravada isnt it?
29. On Improper Livelihoods
A disciple of the Buddha should not, for the sake of gain or with evil intentions, engage in the business of prostitution, selling the wiles and charms of men and women. He must also not cook for himself, milling and pounding grain. Neither may he act as a fortune-teller predicting the gender of children, reading dreams and the like. Nor shall he practice sorcery, work as a trainer of falcons or hunting dogs, nor make a living concocting hundreds and thousands of poisons from deadly snakes, insects, or from gold and silver. Such occupations lack mercy, compassion, and filial piety [toward sentient beings]. Therefore, if a Bodhisattva intentionally engages in these occupations, he commits a secondary offense.
plwk, this is not related with my first question...
...but with the text you provided from the sutras: why cannot a monk cook to himself or pound grain??
In general, an improper livelihood is any occupation that is contrary to the spirit of compassion toward sentient beings. Such occupations include not only traditional ones like fisherman and hunter but also working in slaughter houses or ammunition factories. In the sutras, the Buddha even forbade monks and nuns from tilling the soil, planting crops, or pressing seeds to get oil because such actions often result in the killing of small animals and insects. (Laymen, being subject to a lesser standard of morality, are not prohibited from engaging in such activities. Moreover, they may even be given the opportunity to earn merit and virtue through service to the clergy. Monks and nuns, relieved of daily chores, can then concentrate on their main calling -- practicing the Dharma for the benefit of all.)
No one can stop anyone from thinking what they want to but for a serious buddhist practitioner, the Dharma & Vinaya are what is more important than what I want to think, what do you think?But I still think that sometimes, showing something, could be good.
Yeah, but those stories are oft full of anomalies, inconsistencies and glorified tales at times, I myself would not give it much value because none of them so far are vigorously investigated and verified by independent and credible sources other than their own fans. You do know right, that the Pure Land Path is a Bodhisattva based path that is mapped out with the stages of confidence, aspiration and practice towards the accomplishment of Supreme Buddhahood via buddhanusmrti and not about a fantasy island as some people oft misunderstand nor showing people how flexible a dead man's limbs are by waving it at a camera? What is meaningful (at least for me) from those featured videos are how fortunate that those who are dying have supportive causes and conditions for a wholesome mind approaching death and have a chance to go off peacefully and with dignity. Other than that, I cannot verify anything else.For instance, in the Pure Land section of this forum, we can see that members (myself included) like to read the storys about successful rebirths on Pure Land.
Rebirth is not a siddhi.Isnt that a kind of miracle/siddhi? Should we avoide it?
First of all, how does one know that because of Nembutsu that one developed that ability? There are many reasons involved on how siddhis are developed and Nembutsu may not even be it. The power of a concentrated mind does not necessarily mean a siddhi.Also, if I start to develop, lets say, the ability to see the future on my dreams, because of Nembutsu, should I share that with other members?
If I wanted to do that, I would show them the proper Buddha Dharma with all of its stages of the path and fruit instead of resorting to side circus shows of rainbows, hocus pocus feats, 'now you see, now you don't and snake oil business.Wouldnt be a way to help others increase their faith?
The question is, without all of these 'magic', can one still do good, avoid evil and purify the mind and the answer is a resounding YES.Lets not forget that we live in a very skeptical world, and sometimes, some "magic" could be helpful...
Users browsing this forum: smcj and 16 guests