closed eyes vs. opened eyes

[chickenman]

just curious... some meditation techniques will suggest the meditator keep his eyes opened, focusing on an object, while other techniques suggest the eyes be kept closed. i'm looking for some insight as to why this is and what is the benifit of one over the other.
it is my (limited) experience that with the eyes open it is harder to calm the monkey mind. it would seem logical that the less sensory input one would have to process, the easier it would be to combat distractions. it's hard enough to deal with distracting sounds, let alone processing the distracting images that come from opened eyes. or do i have this all wrong?
any opinions?
thank you.

[Jainarayan]

I can only give my experience. When I do mālā japa I close my eyes and focus on the mantra. In my case it's a name of Vishnu. I also do mālā japa with om mani padme hum. Thoughts come and go, and I just let them. Other times I meditate on Vishnu (my ishta-devata) using a yantra, keeping my eyes half open, but fixed on the yantra. Eventually everything in the surrounding area blurs and I see only the yantra. Again, thoughts come and go, and I let them go. That's all not necessarily right nor wrong for anyone else, just what I do.

[lowlydog]

just curious... some meditation techniques will suggest the meditator keep his eyes opened, focusing on an object, while other techniques suggest the eyes be kept closed. i'm looking for some insight as to why this is and what is the benifit of one over the other.
it is my (limited) experience that with the eyes open it is harder to calm the monkey mind. it would seem logical that the less sensory input one would have to process, the easier it would be to combat distractions. it's hard enough to deal with distracting sounds, let alone processing the distracting images that come from opened eyes. or do i have this all wrong?
any opinions?
thank you.

I'm taught to keep eyes closed at all times during seated meditation, for the less sensory input reason. But the practice is not only meant to be a formal practice it is meant to be developed to the point where one does this 24/7 in all positions the body finds itself in. So as progression is made one can practice with eyes open and eyes closed. We are additionally asked not to practice outdoors for the same reason, it is difficult to pinpoint the fine breath when one is beginning the practice and sitting with wind blowing on the face.

[Johnny Dangerous]

For me closing the eyes helps calm excitement if needed, for instance to further focus on breath. I was taught that the ideal is eyes half open, but wide open or closed eyes are helpful to find the middle ground between over excitement and dullness, IME of course. There are also forms of Shamatha and Vipassana that involve visual objects, obviously can't do those with eyes closed. Sensory input can be hard to deal with, but eventually like everything else it becomes an object of examination by my understanding, so eyes being open or closed seems to just be a means to end, rather than a rule.

Personally I can only do visualizations with my eyes open for some reason, not sure why that is.

[bryanskrantz]

I find it easier for me to do closed eye meditation. staring at the blackness helps me center.

[PadmaVonSamba]

What I do is, if I notice that my eyes are open, I close them and if i notice they are closed I open them.
.
.
.

[lobster]

What I do is, if I notice that my eyes are open, I close them and if i notice they are closed I open them.
.

That is a good approach.

At the moment the
Shikantaza I am using advocates half open, eyes down
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shikantaza

Previously and most natural for me is
lhatong, in which the eyes are wide open and straight ahead
http://vitaminsusa1.blogspot.co.uk/2010 ... ek-14.html

There may be more mind wandering with eyes closed initially, hence the half open recommendation.
Whatever taught and places one at ease is good.

[Karma K Sonam]

Eyes open. I find that when I close my eyes that my monkey mind goes nuts. Eyes open is much, much better. I was taught from the start that it was eyes open as that helped us to be more "present"

[TeeFah]

Hello _/\_

I have seen everyone say everything about this issue x'3 One master say eyes closed, other master say eyes open...In the end it's just confusion left, not really helpful to meditate !
So, why not consider it in the middle then: if more comfortable eyes open, then open eyes. If more comfortable the countrary, then let's do the countrary.
When I meditate I don't really know eyes open/closed. This is my body's buisness, not my mind. Usually when I begin it's eyes closed, but the more long and deep the meditation become, the more they open. But I don't "see" the room or anything, so it's not distracting, because when meditate we have to work on our mind and not on our bodies.
Eyes open can be not good when there is agitation, for example when I meditate eyes open I don't see what happen around me, but a quick movement from a cat or someone entering the door can destroy instantly my focus, as my eyes will be instinctively attracted to the source of the sudden change.
I guess this happen because I am not yet very good For someone that totally have focus or control over instinct and body, it must not be a hindrance.

AUM

[Johnny Dangerous]

Hello _/\_

I have seen everyone say everything about this issue x'3 One master say eyes closed, other master say eyes open...In the end it's just confusion left, not really helpful to meditate !
So, why not consider it in the middle then: if more comfortable eyes open, then open eyes. If more comfortable the countrary, then let's do the countrary.
When I meditate I don't really know eyes open/closed. This is my body's buisness, not my mind. Usually when I begin it's eyes closed, but the more long and deep the meditation become, the more they open. But I don't "see" the room or anything, so it's not distracting, because when meditate we have to work on our mind and not on our bodies.
Eyes open can be not good when there is agitation, for example when I meditate eyes open I don't see what happen around me, but a quick movement from a cat or someone entering the door can destroy instantly my focus, as my eyes will be instinctively attracted to the source of the sudden change.
I guess this happen because I am not yet very good For someone that totally have focus or control over instinct and body, it must not be a hindrance.

AUM

I think the idea is at some point you get better at using things in the environment that are distractions as meditation objects, or even distraction itself, noises and visuals etc. can be used as objects, or at least just appearances you don't need to involve yourself in.. Loud kids help!

[In the bone yard]

just curious... some meditation techniques will suggest the meditator keep his eyes opened, focusing on an object, while other techniques suggest the eyes be kept closed. i'm looking for some insight as to why this is and what is the benifit of one over the other.
it is my (limited) experience that with the eyes open it is harder to calm the monkey mind. it would seem logical that the less sensory input one would have to process, the easier it would be to combat distractions. it's hard enough to deal with distracting sounds, let alone processing the distracting images that come from opened eyes. or do i have this all wrong?
any opinions?
thank you.

I'm taught to keep eyes closed at all times during seated meditation, for the less sensory input reason. But the practice is not only meant to be a formal practice it is meant to be developed to the point where one does this 24/7 in all positions the body finds itself in. So as progression is made one can practice with eyes open and eyes closed. We are additionally asked not to practice outdoors for the same reason, it is difficult to pinpoint the fine breath when one is beginning the practice and sitting with wind blowing on the face.

+1

[Kim O'Hara]

Several people have mentioned the drawback of eyes-open, i.e. distraction, but none have mentioned what (for me) is the main drawback of eyes-closed, i.e. dullness, drowsiness and
I originally learned eyes-closed and was mostly okay with that, then went to a different group where eyes-open was recommended and learned to be okay with that too. I now prefer eyes-open because it is easier to remain alert but I don't think it matters much.


Kim